If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Starvation mode - advice
Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body
off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. As it is now, it seems that I need to eat a little less for every day that comes to keep losing, the body seems to fight back about every microgram. I pretend not to worry of daily fluctuations, though , but I cannot help weighing myself also in the middle of the week , even though I have decided that Sunday is Weighing Day. I wonder if I shall have to keep nibbling till I get to goal weight, which is a long way away (94 kg - 72 kg), or could I expect say a WHOOSH sometimes or that the body actually will start wanting more than under 1000 calories a day. (I am down at about 800 -900 kcal/day now , carbs under 20 g, anything more, and I stall or gain.) In case anybody wonders, I don't feel so ravenous, though, hardly hungry at all, but that is perhaps because I fill my stomach with water if it feels empty. And 2 mugs of coffee (definitively not decaf) in the morning, which I refuse to give up. My family think that I will end up anorectic. Do middle-aged men risk becoming anorectic? May the force be with you Arto F. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
IMHO "Starvation Mode" is a myth. There is a small increase in metabolic
efficiency, if you eat 600 calories per day. This gets exaggerated by wishful thinking of those who hate to count calories. http://www.FitDay.com is a great way to find out how many calories you average. Find your BMR on the internet and the math should be obvious. Note: Fitday over-estimates caloric burn rate. "Arto Frobeus" wrote in message ... Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. As it is now, it seems that I need to eat a little less for every day that comes to keep losing, the body seems to fight back about every microgram. I pretend not to worry of daily fluctuations, though , but I cannot help weighing myself also in the middle of the week , even though I have decided that Sunday is Weighing Day. I wonder if I shall have to keep nibbling till I get to goal weight, which is a long way away (94 kg - 72 kg), or could I expect say a WHOOSH sometimes or that the body actually will start wanting more than under 1000 calories a day. (I am down at about 800 -900 kcal/day now , carbs under 20 g, anything more, and I stall or gain.) In case anybody wonders, I don't feel so ravenous, though, hardly hungry at all, but that is perhaps because I fill my stomach with water if it feels empty. And 2 mugs of coffee (definitively not decaf) in the morning, which I refuse to give up. My family think that I will end up anorectic. Do middle-aged men risk becoming anorectic? May the force be with you Arto F. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
IMHO "Starvation Mode" is a myth. There is a small increase in metabolic
efficiency, if you eat 600 calories per day. This gets exaggerated by wishful thinking of those who hate to count calories. http://www.FitDay.com is a great way to find out how many calories you average. Find your BMR on the internet and the math should be obvious. Note: Fitday over-estimates caloric burn rate. "Arto Frobeus" wrote in message ... Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. As it is now, it seems that I need to eat a little less for every day that comes to keep losing, the body seems to fight back about every microgram. I pretend not to worry of daily fluctuations, though , but I cannot help weighing myself also in the middle of the week , even though I have decided that Sunday is Weighing Day. I wonder if I shall have to keep nibbling till I get to goal weight, which is a long way away (94 kg - 72 kg), or could I expect say a WHOOSH sometimes or that the body actually will start wanting more than under 1000 calories a day. (I am down at about 800 -900 kcal/day now , carbs under 20 g, anything more, and I stall or gain.) In case anybody wonders, I don't feel so ravenous, though, hardly hungry at all, but that is perhaps because I fill my stomach with water if it feels empty. And 2 mugs of coffee (definitively not decaf) in the morning, which I refuse to give up. My family think that I will end up anorectic. Do middle-aged men risk becoming anorectic? May the force be with you Arto F. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 19 Sep 2004 01:06:19 +0200, "Arto Frobeus"
wrote: Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. First, some clarification: Cyclical ketogenic (which is what it sounds like you're attempting to do) is a bit different from just doing the occasional refeed. However, I'm not sure I understand why you would be attempting cyclical ketogenic when you're almost 50 lbs from goal. Are you doing this in conjunction with a weight training program, perhaps? Suggestions: (1) Stay in ketosis to control your appetite. Forget about refeeds. (2) Make sure you're getting enough protein. (3) Increase exercise. (4) Calories matter. Bodyweight (in pounds) x 10 would be a good starting point to estimate daily caloric intake. Start there and take it down a bit if necessary. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. Again, cyclical keto isn't what you want to be doing at this point. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. If you still care to read up on the subject, do an advanced google *groups* search on misc.fitness weights for the terms "refeed", and also "ketogenic". Putting "lyle" in as author will narrow the searches further. http://www.google.com/advanced_group_search?hl=en |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 19 Sep 2004 01:06:19 +0200, "Arto Frobeus"
wrote: Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. First, some clarification: Cyclical ketogenic (which is what it sounds like you're attempting to do) is a bit different from just doing the occasional refeed. However, I'm not sure I understand why you would be attempting cyclical ketogenic when you're almost 50 lbs from goal. Are you doing this in conjunction with a weight training program, perhaps? Suggestions: (1) Stay in ketosis to control your appetite. Forget about refeeds. (2) Make sure you're getting enough protein. (3) Increase exercise. (4) Calories matter. Bodyweight (in pounds) x 10 would be a good starting point to estimate daily caloric intake. Start there and take it down a bit if necessary. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. Again, cyclical keto isn't what you want to be doing at this point. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. If you still care to read up on the subject, do an advanced google *groups* search on misc.fitness weights for the terms "refeed", and also "ketogenic". Putting "lyle" in as author will narrow the searches further. http://www.google.com/advanced_group_search?hl=en |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Arto Frobeus" wrote in message ... Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. As it is now, it seems that I need to eat a little less for every day that comes to keep losing, the body seems to fight back about every microgram. I pretend not to worry of daily fluctuations, though , but I cannot help weighing myself also in the middle of the week , even though I have decided that Sunday is Weighing Day. I wonder if I shall have to keep nibbling till I get to goal weight, which is a long way away (94 kg - 72 kg), or could I expect say a WHOOSH sometimes or that the body actually will start wanting more than under 1000 calories a day. (I am down at about 800 -900 kcal/day now , carbs under 20 g, anything more, and I stall or gain.) In case anybody wonders, I don't feel so ravenous, though, hardly hungry at all, but that is perhaps because I fill my stomach with water if it feels empty. And 2 mugs of coffee (definitively not decaf) in the morning, which I refuse to give up. My family think that I will end up anorectic. Do middle-aged men risk becoming anorectic? May the force be with you Arto F. Everyone has opinions, and I agree with the previous posters. They are knowledgeable. I would like to add that you should not let a stall discourage you. It's almost certainly going to happen. I know it sucks when things were working so well for you, and then suddenly nothing changes, but stick to the plan. Things will happen again, it just might take a week or a month, no way to predict. In aviation, there is a thing called "ground effect." It happens when you are taking off, and again when you are landing. A small plane, in that phase, kind of 'floats' along. When landing, you wait for the plane to start sinking towards the ground again, and then flare. There is no constant. Relax and enjoy the diet regimen you are on. Please don't think you have to change anything because you're not seeing results right now. Eventually, they will happen. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"Arto Frobeus" wrote in message ... Now, I wonder if any of you have any experience about getting the body off starvation mode. Other than the "refeeding" theory. I dare not try again the "refeeding" theory, that one should "eat up" a little to get the fat burning going again when when on a plateau for a longer time. It backfired on me and I finished eating also all the forbidden things, gaining 10 kg, until I started counting calories, and cutting my carbs to induction level. I have googled but became none the wiser and ask the group of your experience. As it is now, it seems that I need to eat a little less for every day that comes to keep losing, the body seems to fight back about every microgram. I pretend not to worry of daily fluctuations, though , but I cannot help weighing myself also in the middle of the week , even though I have decided that Sunday is Weighing Day. I wonder if I shall have to keep nibbling till I get to goal weight, which is a long way away (94 kg - 72 kg), or could I expect say a WHOOSH sometimes or that the body actually will start wanting more than under 1000 calories a day. (I am down at about 800 -900 kcal/day now , carbs under 20 g, anything more, and I stall or gain.) In case anybody wonders, I don't feel so ravenous, though, hardly hungry at all, but that is perhaps because I fill my stomach with water if it feels empty. And 2 mugs of coffee (definitively not decaf) in the morning, which I refuse to give up. My family think that I will end up anorectic. Do middle-aged men risk becoming anorectic? May the force be with you Arto F. Everyone has opinions, and I agree with the previous posters. They are knowledgeable. I would like to add that you should not let a stall discourage you. It's almost certainly going to happen. I know it sucks when things were working so well for you, and then suddenly nothing changes, but stick to the plan. Things will happen again, it just might take a week or a month, no way to predict. In aviation, there is a thing called "ground effect." It happens when you are taking off, and again when you are landing. A small plane, in that phase, kind of 'floats' along. When landing, you wait for the plane to start sinking towards the ground again, and then flare. There is no constant. Relax and enjoy the diet regimen you are on. Please don't think you have to change anything because you're not seeing results right now. Eventually, they will happen. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
I've never heard of a middle aged man being anorexic.
Becky P. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
I've never heard of a middle aged man being anorexic.
Becky P. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Concordia wrote:
First, some clarification: Cyclical ketogenic (which is what it sounds like you're attempting to do) is a bit different from just doing the occasional refeed. However, I'm not sure I understand why you would be attempting cyclical ketogenic when you're almost 50 lbs from goal. Are you doing this in conjunction with a weight training program, perhaps? Suggestions: (1) Stay in ketosis to control your appetite. Forget about refeeds. (2) Make sure you're getting enough protein. (3) Increase exercise. (4) Calories matter. Bodyweight (in pounds) x 10 would be a good starting point to estimate daily caloric intake. Start there and take it down a bit if necessary. Again, cyclical keto isn't what you want to be doing at this point. If you still care to read up on the subject, do an advanced google *groups* search on misc.fitness weights for the terms "refeed", and also "ketogenic". Putting "lyle" in as author will narrow the searches further. I do not understand one word. What qualified gibberish is that? What ever in the world is cyclical ketogenic? (You do not actually need to answer and explain). What I am doing is trying to lose weight. This thing about refeed is something I read about nearly a year ago, and I understood it so that it might help me out of plateau if I overeat a couple of times to get the system going again. I did that and could not stop overeating for six months (that means a lot of lovely carbs in the food), something like what happens to alcoholics when they fall for temptation after a dry period. So much for refeed. Gained back half of what I had lost but my metabolism obviously had decided to keep the new heavier weight, because I could get weight loss going againonly by cutting portions drastically. I am not doing Atkins with any interest in serious scientific detail. I can count my carbs and calories, I can read the scales and I know when I grow too big for my clothes, or when I can go try one size smaller to put on. And I know when I see a waistline appear in the mirror (some day, I hope). If I eat as much calories at present as the suggested formula above I gain weight. I dislike doing mathematics. I weigh my food, look up the calories and carbs from list the I have set up on the fridge door and have thus come to the conclusion that maximum about 800-900 calories keeps me losing. We'll see how it is next Sunday, today I had gone down 800g from last Sunday. (but now, in the evening I am actually one kilo heavier.) Why I wrote my piece in the first place is that my body obviously is fighting against the weight loss very strongly and I am seriously concerned if eating very little calories of which a greater part are protein (chicken, pork, fish, only a little lettuce, cucumber or broccoli to give it some colour) is harmful in some way inthe long run or if my body will return to burning calories at more normal rate. The question actually is, is there a way to get out of this starvation mode, as I have seen it called so often, or shall I just go on and see what happens and hope for continued weight loss. I am not really interested in any conversation or hairsplitting theories about what starvation mode is actually called, or is there anything like starvation mode at all or whatever. I use that term out of convenience, in lack of anything better. As far as I know I am not in ketosis, at least I have not got the "dragon breath" yet I developed earlier. Ketostix are not available in Sweden. Would something they call lacmus (litmos) paper do? The official Swedish medical opinion is that Atkins diet is dangerous for your health and leads to all kinds of unexpected unpleasant illnesses and death. Nevertheless, light in darkness has been found. Some Atkins Nutritonal low carb products have found their way to shops that mainly sell alternative herbal medicine and such. Not to food markets, probably as they are in some way a suspicious product conncted to a fatal diet :-) Arto F. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Another Starvation Mode Question | ?fooguy? | General Discussion | 5 | June 5th, 2004 09:43 PM |
Gastric Bypass = starvation mode??? | Mack | General Discussion | 13 | January 25th, 2004 10:25 PM |
Starvation mode | Luna | Low Carbohydrate Diets | 16 | January 24th, 2004 08:23 PM |
Out of lurk mode, seeking advice | Sas | Low Carbohydrate Diets | 9 | October 26th, 2003 04:43 PM |
Is this healthy? (starvation mode) | HavingFun | General Discussion | 6 | September 22nd, 2003 08:53 PM |