If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Health Benefits of Fasting
The Health Benefits of Fasting
by Will Carroll There has been much contention in the scientific field about whether or not fasting is beneficial to one's health. Fasting is an integral part of many of the major religions including Islam, Judaism and Christianity. Many are dubious as to whether the physiological effects are as beneficial as the spiritual promoted by these religions. There is a significant community of alternative healers who believe that fasting can do wonders for the human body. Fasting technically commences within the first twelve to twenty-four hours of the fast. A fast does not chemically begin until the carbohydrate stores in the body begin to be used as an energy source. The fast will continue as long as fat and carbohydrate stores are used for energy, as opposed to protein stores. Once protein stores begin to be depleted for energy (resulting in loss of muscle mass) a person is technically starving. Detoxification is the foremost argument presented by advocates of fasting. "Detoxification is a normal body process of eliminating or neutralizing toxins through the colon, liver, kidneys, lungs, lymph glands, and skin." This process is precipitated by fasting because when food is no longer entering the body, the body turns to fat reserves for energy. "Human fat is valued at 3,500 calories per pound," a number that would lead one to believe that surviving on one pound of fat every day would provide a body with enough energy to function normally. These fat reserves were created when excess glucose and carbohydrates were not used for energy or growth, not excreted, and therefore converted into fat. When the fat reserves are used for energy during a fast, it releases the chemicals from the fatty acids into the system which are then eliminated through the aforementioned organs. A second prescribed benefit of fasting is the healing process that begins in the body during a fast. During a fast energy is diverted away from the digestive system due to its lack of use and towards the metabolism and immune system. The healing process during a fast is precipitated by the body's search for energy sources. Abnormal growths within the body, tumors and the like, do not have the full support of the body's supplies and therefore are more susceptible to autolysis. Furthermore, "production of protein for replacement of damaged cells (protein synthesis) occurs more efficiently because fewer 'mistakes' are made by the DNA/RNA genetic controls which govern this process." A higher efficiency in protein synthesis results in healthier cells, tissues and organs. This is one reason that animals stop eating when they are wounded, and why humans lose hunger during influenza. Hunger has been proven absent in illnesses such as gastritis, tonsillitis and colds. Therefore, when one is fasting, the person is consciously diverting energy from the digestive system to the immune system. In addition, there is a reduction in core body temperature. This is a direct result of the slower metabolic rate and general bodily functions. Following a drop in blood sugar level and using the reserves of glucose found in liver glycogen, the basal metabolic rate (BMR) is reduced in order to conserve as much energy within the body as can be provided. Growth hormones are also released during a fast, due to the greater efficiency in hormone production. Finally, the most scientifically proven advantage to fasting is the feeling of rejuvenation and extended life expectancy. Part of this phenomenon is caused by a number of the benefits mentioned above. A slower metabolic rate, more efficient protein production, an improved immune system, and the increased production of hormones contributes to this long-term benefit of fasting. In addition to the Human Growth Hormone that is released more frequently during a fast, an anti-aging hormone is also produced more efficiently. "The only reliable way to extend the lifespan of a mammal is under-nutrition without malnutrition." A study was performed on earthworms that demonstrated the extension of life due to fasting. The experiment was performed in the 1930s by isolating one worm and putting it on a cycle of fasting and feeding. The isolated worm outlasted its relatives by 19 generations, while still maintaining its youthful physiological traits. The worm was able to survive on its own tissue for months. Once the size of the worm began to decrease, the scientists would resume feeding it at which point it showed great vigor and energy. "The life-span extension of these worms was the equivalent of keeping a man alive for 600 to 700 years." In conclusion, it seems that there are many reasons to consider fasting as a benefit to one's health. The body rids itself of the toxins that have built up in our fat stores throughout the years. The body heals itself, repairs all the damaged organs during a fast. And finally there is good evidence to show that regulated fasting contributes to longer life. However, many doctors warn against fasting for extended periods of time without supervision. There are still many doctors today who deny all of these points and claim that fasting is detrimental to one's health and have evidence to back their statements. The idea of depriving a body of what society has come to view as so essential to our survival in order to heal continues to be a topic of controversy. The complete version of this paper can be found at: http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/biology.../wcarroll.html |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Health Benefits of Fasting
"John S." quoted:
The Health Benefits of Fasting by Will Carroll There has been much contention in the scientific field about whether or not fasting is beneficial to one's health. Fasting is an integral part of many of the major religions including Islam, Judaism and Christianity. Many are dubious as to whether the physiological effects are as beneficial as the spiritual promoted by these religions. There is a significant community of alternative healers who believe that fasting can do wonders for the human body. The problem I see is diet support groups get enough visitors with eating disorders that discussing fasting is very problematic. it is a very bad idea to point out benefits of fasting to anyone with an eating disorder who should work at developing regular eating habits not get tempted to take extreme actions. While properly done fasting isn't extreme, folks with eating disorders (and many without) don't know when a fast becomes starvation. Consider that "hunger strikes" are sometimes called fasting. Fasting technically commences within the first twelve to twenty-four hours of the fast. A fast does not chemically begin until the carbohydrate stores in the body begin to be used as an energy source. And not even then - That's going into ketosis. Eating the diet of a successful predator will put you into ketosis. Which brings up the question - If there are benefits to fasting, how many are actually from being in ketosis, and vice versa? The fast will continue as long as fat and carbohydrate stores are used for energy, as opposed to protein stores. Once protein stores begin to be depleted for energy (resulting in loss of muscle mass) a person is technically starving. But how to tell, and how to take into account the fact that the body will tend to drop lean mass before fat in order to reduce its current energy consumption? Folks who yoyo diet can end up "skinny fat" from dropping lean mass like this. A second prescribed benefit of fasting is the healing process that begins in the body during a fast. During a fast energy is diverted away from the digestive system due to its lack of use and towards the metabolism and immune system. The healing process during a fast is precipitated by the body's search for energy sources. Abnormal growths within the body, tumors and the like, do not have the full support of the body's supplies and therefore are more susceptible to autolysis. Again I wonder how much of this happens while in ketosis as a result of a successful predator diet compared to fasting. Except the digestion part. In addition, there is a reduction in core body temperature. This is a direct result of the slower metabolic rate and general bodily functions. Following a drop in blood sugar level and using the reserves of glucose found in liver glycogen, the basal metabolic rate (BMR) is reduced in order to conserve as much energy within the body as can be provided. Various studies of VLCD show T3 output starting to drop in two weeks in, but as I read them and consider what I've read over the years about loss rates it appears to me that the less you have to lose the sooner it happens the more you have to lose the later it happens and at some point (maybe 100+ pounds to lose) it doesn't happen at all until you're below that weight. But those studies are with eating protein and fat. That BMR reduction should happen sooner in a fast makes sense. Growth hormones are also released during a fast, due to the greater efficiency in hormone production. Among breeds of dogs, the small breeds live longer the larger breeds live shorter lives. I don't know if there have ever been studies of smaller people living longer, but the 90+ year old folks I can remember have been small. So maybe keeping growth hormone low helps longevity? Finally, the most scientifically proven advantage to fasting is the feeling of rejuvenation and extended life expectancy. An edition of Discover magazine about 6 months ago covered caloric reduction and longevity increase. One suggestion is the biggest contributor was lower insulin. This too suggests an advantage to low carb. Part of this phenomenon is caused by a number of the benefits mentioned above. A slower metabolic rate, more efficient protein production, an improved immune system, and the increased production of hormones contributes to this long-term benefit of fasting. In addition to the Human Growth Hormone that is released more frequently during a fast, an anti-aging hormone is also produced more efficiently. "The only reliable way to extend the lifespan of a mammal is under-nutrition without malnutrition." Under nutrition without malnutrition - Doesn't that sound like any good low carb or low fat plan? Or any low calorie plan that carefully controls what is eaten to make sure nutrients are plentiful? In conclusion, it seems that there are many reasons to consider fasting as a benefit to one's health. But if anyone ever in your life has asked you about an eating disorder, run away! |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Health Benefits of Fasting
Much thanks for your comments on the article. I was in such a hurry
to contribute to the group that I forgot to make comment on why I was posting it. I'm not necessarily in favor of fasting or trying to promote it and I didn't take the time to check the data in the article for accuracy. Moreover, I also didn't consider the influence it might have on people who might have a tendency to starve or undereat. The reason I posted it was because conceptually the idea of keeping careful watch on caloric intake and noting the benefits that might result from lower caloric intake rather than higher caloric intake seemed important to discuss. John S. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Health Benefits of Mushroom | Philospher | General Discussion | 0 | August 17th, 2007 12:31 PM |
Health Benefits of Straberries | [email protected] | General Discussion | 3 | December 13th, 2006 07:07 PM |
yoga and its benefits for your health | [email protected] | General Discussion | 0 | July 29th, 2006 04:51 PM |
The Health Benefits of Whole-Grains | Mr-Natural-Health | Low Carbohydrate Diets | 1 | February 21st, 2006 01:40 AM |
OT sun tea vs regular tea health benefits | sprudil | Low Carbohydrate Diets | 19 | August 23rd, 2004 03:07 AM |