If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
Eric's comment made me want to bring up the subject of doing low-carb on a budget: "Eric" wrote i We're talking at least six dollars a day if you try to eat 2000 calories in meat and fish with some level of variety. That adds up to some serious bread, doesn't it? Rather than blather, I thought I'd just open up the topic to see what everyone has to say. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
"em" wrote in message ...
Eric's comment made me want to bring up the subject of doing low-carb on a budget: "Eric" wrote i We're talking at least six dollars a day if you try to eat 2000 calories in meat and fish with some level of variety. That adds up to some serious bread, doesn't it? Rather than blather, I thought I'd just open up the topic to see what everyone has to say. The budget for our family of 3 is $75/week. I buy one "variety pack" of meat from a local butcher that contains 45# of chicken, beef, and pork of various cuts and sorts, for $74.95. The rest goes into fresh and frozen produce, dairy (including eggs), fish, spices/seasonings/condiments mostly, with the occasional - approx. monthly - package of sweetener, jar of the coffee substitute I drink, and nuts/seeds. We don't eat fruit for the most part, but I do have frozen berries in my "shop" (a big kitchen, actually, out of which I run my business) and will sometimes take a half-cup or so for a sauce or dessert. If the budget allows, when one of our foods goes on sale, I buy as much as I can even if it means buying less of something else. When we ate packaged, prepared, and carby foods, I couldn't shop for $75/week. Low carb is cheaper for us. -- Sherry lowcarb.owly.net |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
UsenetID wrote:
"em" wrote in message ... Eric's comment made me want to bring up the subject of doing low-carb on a budget: "Eric" wrote i We're talking at least six dollars a day if you try to eat 2000 calories in meat and fish with some level of variety. That adds up to some serious bread, doesn't it? Rather than blather, I thought I'd just open up the topic to see what everyone has to say. Eric appears fixated on the all meat approach to Atkins and low carb. Beef and pork average around 400 to 600 Cals per 6 ounce serving, so the 2000 Calorie intake would require 30 to 20 ounces of beef/pork or call it roughly 1.5 pounds of meat per day. Fattier cuts of meat would reduce the required daily poundage by 20 to 40%. Vegetable oil fats are a pretty cheap form of calories, also. The price range of this much meat can range from $2 / lb to $10 / lb so this could be $3.00 / day to $15.00 per day. The basic answer on expense as raised by Eric is "it depends". I tend to now ignore much of what is claimed about reasons to support oddish forms of low carb diets. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
On Nov 11, 10:58 pm, "UsenetID" wrote:
"em" wrote in ... Eric's comment made me want to bring up the subject of doing low-carb on a budget: "Eric" wrote i We're talking at least six dollars a day if you try to eat 2000 calories in meat and fish with some level of variety. That adds up to some serious bread, doesn't it? Rather than blather, I thought I'd just open up the topic to see what everyone has to say. The budget for our family of 3 is $75/week. I buy one "variety pack" of meat from a local butcher that contains 45# of chicken, beef, and pork of various cuts and sorts, for $74.95. The rest goes into fresh and frozen produce, dairy (including eggs), fish, spices/seasonings/condiments mostly, with the occasional - approx. monthly - package of sweetener, jar of the coffee substitute I drink, and nuts/seeds. How much of that stuff do you get for $.05? We don't eat fruit for the most part, but I do have frozen berries in my "shop" (a big kitchen, actually, out of which I run my business) and will sometimes take a half-cup or so for a sauce or dessert. If the budget allows, when one of our foods goes on sale, I buy as much as I can even if it means buying less of something else. When we ate packaged, prepared, and carby foods, I couldn't shop for $75/week. Low carb is cheaper for us. -- Sherry lowcarb.owly.net Yes, I was going to bring that up too. If you're an out of control blivitt eating everything is sight, you're going to eat a whole lot less when you're on LC. Not sure it will entirely offset the higher cost of real food, but it certainly is a factor. And it also depends on what kind of carby stuff you were eating. You can also reduce the cost by using more chicken and less beef, fish, etc. Chicken is on sale here for 40 to 50% off at one supermarket or another every week. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
em wrote:
Rather than blather, I thought I'd just open up the topic to see what everyone has to say. It depends on how you were eating before; if you were eating a lot of processed junk, going low-carb with real food is cheaper. But that's really not about it being low-carb, that's about eating whole foods. And it's actually cheaper to eat high-carb whole foods... wheat berries are darned cheap; you can get 100 lbs of them for under $10 and that would stretch anyone's food budget. Grain is cheap; there's no getting around that - cutting it from your diet raises average food cost. On the other hand, there's some seriously expensive costs associated with not eating well. Even one day in the hospital more than wipes out a year's worth of carefully frugal grocery shopping; it gets a lot worse if you're out-of-work for health reasons. Even on high-carb, you need to get sufficient protein and the only really cheap source of protein is eggs whether you are low-carb or high-carb. IMO, the primary thing to save money low-carbing is a freezer; if you buy meats in bulk, you can save a LOT of money on them. I will have 3 or 4 turkeys in my freezer before the holiday is over as this is the cheap time to buy them. I have been trying hard not to care about food cost since my heart attack, insisting on buying pasture-raised animal products which are more expensive, preferring organic fresh produce over regular, using avocado and coconut oils, etc. Some of the individual prices of stuff I buy freaks me out, but I've not been spending more overall. -- http://www.ornery-geeks.org/consulting/ |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
Jackie Patti wrote:
I have been trying hard not to care about food cost since my heart attack, insisting on buying pasture-raised animal products which are more expensive, preferring organic fresh produce over regular, using avocado and coconut oils, etc. Some of the individual prices of stuff I buy freaks me out, but I've not been spending more overall. Jackie, I hope you don't mind me asking, but did you have your heart attack before eating low carb? If not, how did you change your diet? O |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
Ophelia wrote:
Jackie Patti wrote: I have been trying hard not to care about food cost since my heart attack, insisting on buying pasture-raised animal products which are more expensive, preferring organic fresh produce over regular, using avocado and coconut oils, etc. Some of the individual prices of stuff I buy freaks me out, but I've not been spending more overall. Jackie, I hope you don't mind me asking, but did you have your heart attack before eating low carb? If not, how did you change your diet? I've been low-carbing for over a decade for bg control, but lost bg control subsequent to a pancreasitis attack, then had the heart attack, an unsuccessful angio and thus a bypass. I have changed my diet in a number of ways since then. First being that I record the carbs, protein and calories of every meal in order to dose the insulin. Insulin makes me much more aware of what I eat and cuts the snacking back a lot since I rarely am hungry enough to want an extra shot. I doubled my vegetable intake - I now buy 10-15 lbs of fresh produce every week and race to eat it before it goes bad. Most of what I buy is organic, considerably more expensive. I eat more fruit too, pretty much a serving of berries, melon, kiwi, half a pomegranate or such once or twice a day. I cut out eating quite so much low-carb junk food like the tortillas and rather make more things out of flax and almond meal. I've reduce the overall saturated fat in my diet because I am buying all pasture-raised meat and dairy now, which has healthier fats. It's more expensive, so I eat a bit less of this stuff.... though every meal still starts with a base of protein: meat, poultry, fish, eggs, yogurt, cottage cheese, raw hard cheese - all from pasture-raised animals so a lot more expensive than I'm used to. I've been pushing myself to eat fish more often. Mostly tuna and tilapia, rarely scallops cause they're expensive. I also take 6g fish oil daily. I threw out all the vegetable oils except olive oil and started buying avocado oil as well. I quit the Lindt 85% chocolate and started making coconut bark instead (I've posted the recipe here, so you can Google for it). This gets me coconut oil in my diet for it's purported health benefits without increasing my saturated fat since it's replacing cocoa butter. I used to drink a pot of coffee and at least 2 liters of Diet Pepsi daily, if not more. Now, I drink one cup of real coffee, then switch to decaf for the rest of the day. And for cold drinks, I drink stevia-sweetened lemonade or limeade. Sometimes dilute cranberry juice (real juice, not the "cocktail" stuff which is full of sugar). I also take a multivitamin, B-complex, pantothenic acid and niacin daily now aside from my prescription meds. I count the supplements in my food budget, though not the medications. The thing that doesn't quite make sense to me is that I *know* I am buying more expensive meats, veggies, fruits, dairy products, eggs and buying more supplements, but am not spending more money overall than I was doing before. It's hard for me to believe I was spending *that* much on Diet Pepsi and low-carb tortillas... -- http://www.ornery-geeks.org/consulting/ |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
Jackie Patti wrote:
I've been low-carbing for over a decade for bg control, but lost bg control subsequent to a pancreasitis attack, then had the heart attack, an unsuccessful angio and thus a bypass. I have changed my diet in a number of ways since then. Was the heart attack directly attributable to the pancreasitis? When you say you had been lcing for the bg control, are you diabetic? Sorry if I am being too blunt but this fascinates me. If you prefer not to repond I will undestand. I don't have a clue what my bg is. Ought I to know, or would know if there was a problem? First being that I record the carbs, protein and calories of every meal in order to dose the insulin. Insulin makes me much more aware of what I eat and cuts the snacking back a lot since I rarely am hungry enough to want an extra shot. I doubled my vegetable intake - I now buy 10-15 lbs of fresh produce every week and race to eat it before it goes bad. Most of what I buy is organic, considerably more expensive. Quite! We buy everything we can, organic. I eat more fruit too, pretty much a serving of berries, melon, kiwi, half a pomegranate or such once or twice a day. I cut out eating quite so much low-carb junk food like the tortillas and rather make more things out of flax and almond meal. I've reduce the overall saturated fat in my diet because I am buying all pasture-raised meat and dairy now, which has healthier fats. It's more expensive, so I eat a bit less of this stuff.... though every meal still starts with a base of protein: meat, poultry, fish, eggs, yogurt, cottage cheese, raw hard cheese - all from pasture-raised animals so a lot more expensive than I'm used to. Hmm... we don't have that recorded on our food, although I always choose organic. I wonder if that has anything to do with pasture raised? I had thought saturated fat was the healthy one, although you have cut it down, not out. I've been pushing myself to eat fish more often. Mostly tuna and tilapia, rarely scallops cause they're expensive. I also take 6g fish oil daily. I threw out all the vegetable oils except olive oil and started buying avocado oil as well. I quit the Lindt 85% chocolate and started making coconut bark instead (I've posted the recipe here, so you can Google for it). This gets me coconut oil in my diet for it's purported health benefits without increasing my saturated fat since it's replacing cocoa butter. I shall search for it, thank you I used to drink a pot of coffee and at least 2 liters of Diet Pepsi daily, if not more. Now, I drink one cup of real coffee, then switch to decaf for the rest of the day. And for cold drinks, I drink stevia-sweetened lemonade or limeade. Sometimes dilute cranberry juice (real juice, not the "cocktail" stuff which is full of sugar). I also take a multivitamin, B-complex, pantothenic acid and niacin daily now aside from my prescription meds. I count the supplements in my food budget, though not the medications. I don't know what the latter two are, but we take a multivit, B complex, and Cod liver oil. The thing that doesn't quite make sense to me is that I *know* I am buying more expensive meats, veggies, fruits, dairy products, eggs and buying more supplements, but am not spending more money overall than I was doing before. It's hard for me to believe I was spending *that* much on Diet Pepsi and low-carb tortillas... I can only think that the junk doesn't feed you and you need more to feel satisfied. Well done Jackie. I think you are very clever to do all that. I hope it means your health is improving or at least stable. Many thanks O |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
Ophelia wrote:
Jackie Patti wrote: I've been low-carbing for over a decade for bg control, but lost bg control subsequent to a pancreasitis attack, then had the heart attack, an unsuccessful angio and thus a bypass. I have changed my diet in a number of ways since then. Was the heart attack directly attributable to the pancreasitis? When you say you had been lcing for the bg control, are you diabetic? Yes, I've been a T2 diabetic for almost 2 decades now. I am the one who has attributed the heart attack to the diabetes being uncontrolled. Diabetics have the same chance of having a heart attack as someone who has already had one. High bg gycosylates serum proteins, making them sticky and causing plaque buildup. And high bg screws up your lipids... I had elevated LDL and trigylcerides in the hospital until my bg was controlled, then they were cut in half and my LDL came in at under 60. I'm a 45-yr-old woman, so having a heart attack was kinda not in the odds for me yet, which is why I think it was the elevated bg as that is my primary risk factor. Sorry if I am being too blunt but this fascinates me. If you prefer not to repond I will undestand. I've already discussed it all over Usenet. In short, my heart attack likely occured because I was scared of insulin and didn't treat my high bg - so it was caused by stupidity. I don't have a clue what my bg is. Ought I to know, or would know if there was a problem? It's hard to say. If your bg is very out-of-control, you tend to have certain symptoms - you're thirsty a lot and also need to pee a lot. There's also a tendency towards infections like boils and yeast infections and such. You have to be pretty seriously elevated to have those symptoms though. Doctors tend to screen by testing fasting blood glucose. The problem is, the way the diseases progresses is by losing blood glucose control after meals first, so the fasting numbers don't get high until you're already fairly screwed up. Most diabetics already have damage due to diabetes before they're diagnosed as it's symptoms that cause a doctor to look further. Lots more info about diabetes he http://www.phlaunt.com/diabetes/ If you are concerned, you can buy a cheap meter and test for a week or two to see how you do. In general, the meters are cheap, often free, it's the test strips that are expensive. Walmart has a very cheap storebrand meter with cheap strips. Well-controlled diabetics test after meals to see what foods raise their bg. There's a good page about testing he http://www.alt-support-diabetes.org/NewlyDiagnosed.htm Given that the main thing that lowers bg and improves insulin resistance in most T2s is a low-carb diet and exercise, you're likely doing most of what needs to be done anyways. I've reduce the overall saturated fat in my diet because I am buying all pasture-raised meat and dairy now, which has healthier fats. It's more expensive, so I eat a bit less of this stuff.... though every meal still starts with a base of protein: meat, poultry, fish, eggs, yogurt, cottage cheese, raw hard cheese - all from pasture-raised animals so a lot more expensive than I'm used to. Hmm... we don't have that recorded on our food, although I always choose organic. I wonder if that has anything to do with pasture raised? I had thought saturated fat was the healthy one, although you have cut it down, not out. I think many organic regulations require the animals to have *some* access to pasture, but that's not necessarily pasture-raised. I have a freezer so can mostly buy meat from farmers. With cheese and other dairy products, I've had to research to find out which brands are pasture-raised. It's usually tiny organic brands no one's ever heard of. I also take a multivitamin, B-complex, pantothenic acid and niacin daily now aside from my prescription meds. I count the supplements in my food budget, though not the medications. I don't know what the latter two are, but we take a multivit, B complex, and Cod liver oil. The latter two are specific to heart disease; they're higher doses of two individual B vitamins. I tried the cod liver oil as it would've replaced 6 fish oil tablets and 2 vitamin D tablets. But it makes me retch; I can't stand the stuff. The thing that doesn't quite make sense to me is that I *know* I am buying more expensive meats, veggies, fruits, dairy products, eggs and buying more supplements, but am not spending more money overall than I was doing before. It's hard for me to believe I was spending *that* much on Diet Pepsi and low-carb tortillas... I can only think that the junk doesn't feed you and you need more to feel satisfied. Could be. Before the heart attack, I could eat two small pizzas, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella and pepperoni baked on a low-carb tortilla. When I started recording things, I discovered those suckers had a thousand calories each. I still have them now-and-then, but one is quite sufficient! I found when I started eating more veggies, I was craving more and more veggies for a while. It got kind of ridiculous how much vegetables I was eating while still wanting more - so I do suspect I might have had some sort of deficiencies. Well done Jackie. I think you are very clever to do all that. I hope it means your health is improving or at least stable. I doubt I can credit the diet; I'll improve as time passes anyways as it takes time to heal up from surgeries. But I'm rather motivated to do everything that will help right now, so have made lots of dietary changes. -- http://www.ornery-geeks.org/consulting/ |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Low-carb on a tight budget
"Ophelia" writes:
I don't have a clue what my bg is. Ought I to know, or would know if there was a problem? I think it's a very useful thing to know. If you're overweight, there's a good chance that your blood sugar isn't well controlled. If your BG doesn't come back to normal within two hours after eating, that means either A) your pancreas isn't producing as much insulin as it should, or B) it's producing insulin like crazy, but you're insulin resistant enough that all that insulin isn't able to convince your cells to pull the glucose out of your blood. The latter may eventually wear your pancreas out to the point of Type II diabetes. A doctor can do a fasting BG test, but for $50-$100 in equipment and strips you can test yourself multiple times: fasting, when waking up, one hour and two hours after meals, after exercise, etc. That'll give you a much better picture of how your body handled glucose than a single test will. You can also test after foods like sugar alcohols, which seem to cause a BG spike in some people and not others, to see how they affect you. When I started testing, just seeing the numbers was the shock to my system that I needed to make me realize what I was doing to my health. I could no longer tell myself it wouldn't hurt to have one more pizza binge, that I could put off the diet tomorrow, because it wasn't just about weight loss anymore, but about quality of life and making sure I won't be getting anything amputated or going blind. When you look at that meter and see 190 two hours after a carby meal, knowing that anything over 140 means organ damage is occurring *right now*, that's hard to brush off. On the other hand, seeing a nice healthy 89 two hours after a great low-carb lasagna (with Swiss chard for noodles) is really gratifying. Hmm... we don't have that recorded on our food, although I always choose organic. I wonder if that has anything to do with pasture raised? I had thought saturated fat was the healthy one, although you have cut it down, not out. Saturated fat isn't bad for you like we've been taught, but it's not especially good for you either. It really depends on what else you're eating, which is why some studies made saturated fats look bad: people were eating them in combination with too many carbs and not enough omega-3 fatty acids. Your body knows how to convert saturated fat into unsaturated, which is good, because saturated fats aren't very flexible (think butter compared to olive oil), so you don't want a lot of them making up your cell membranes. However, this process requires certain enzymes, and the production process that leads to those enzymes begins with omega-3 fatty acids. If you're eating the typical modern diet that has an omega-6/omega-3 ratio of twenty or more to one, you may not produce enough of those enzymes, and your cell membranes will be stiffer than would be best. This can worsen insulin resistance, among other things, because it makes it harder for the receptors in the membrane to move around and do things. So if you're eating right otherwise, saturated fats aren't a threat the way they are to the grain eaters, because you'll be able to use them well. If you're eating low-carb, you're almost automatically going to have a better omega-6/omega-3 ratio than "normal", because most grains are very high in omega-6. Fish oil and sardines can improve the ratio even more, and as Jackie said, pasture raised animal products are better than those from grain-fed animals. Trans-fats are the only fat that's truly harmful in all cases. Like saturated fat, they're inflexible, but unlike saturated fat, they haven't been around long enough for us to evolve a mechanism for converting them into a flexible form. So the body just plugs them into the cell walls as-is and hopes for the best, especially if you're short on healthy fats. You really don't want to consume *any* trans-fats, ever, if you can possibly avoid it. (Most of this is condensed from Protein Power Life Plan, by the way; so grab a copy of that for a detailed explanation.) -- Aaron -- 285/254/200 -- aaron.baugher.biz |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
No Cal, No Carb Chocolate Syrup + Strawberry Sugarless Preserves+ Lo Carb Flatbread | Jbuch | Low Carbohydrate Diets | 1 | November 30th, 2006 04:41 AM |
high-carb vegetarian + low-carb carnivore = wedded bliss? | [email protected] | Low Carbohydrate Diets | 37 | October 9th, 2005 07:11 AM |
Does anyone know about this fat burner called Tight by Sann | [email protected] | General Discussion | 5 | June 9th, 2005 10:15 PM |
could someone pls recommend another quality budget site that won't just send to USA/Europe? | boMBerMAn RUles WitH fIST OF FURy | General Discussion | 0 | January 16th, 2004 04:28 AM |
OT - traveling (and eating) on a shoestring budget | determined | General Discussion | 6 | November 7th, 2003 12:21 AM |